Family Law Story Series | Love or Money? - Part 2
“If We Get Married, Doesn't Half of Everything Become Mine?”
Marriage is often viewed as a complete partnership of love and shared futures. But when one partner enters the relationship with significant property or a thriving business, assumptions about an automatic 50/50 division can lead to painful misunderstandings.
What actually happens to assets owned before marriage if the relationship breaks down, and how can couples clarify their financial future before walking down the aisle?
New to the story? Catch up on Part 1: The Prenup That Almost Ruined the Wedding
Emma Meets with a Family Lawyer
Previously, Daniel asked Emma to sign a prenuptial agreement to protect his two investment properties and business.
Emma was offended. She believed Daniel's family did not trust her.
Determined to understand her rights, Emma arranged an appointment with a family lawyer.
Emma: “Daniel's parents want him to keep all his pre-marriage assets if we divorce. But once we're married, aren't we supposed to share everything?”
Lawyer: “Marriage doesn't automatically mean you each own half of the other's assets. But if your marriage breaks down, property division is not necessarily determined solely by whose name is on the title.”
Emma: “So even if Daniel bought his houses before meeting me, they could still be considered?”
Lawyer: “Yes. Property owned before marriage can be relevant to a property settlement. The Court considers various matters, including the parties' contributions and their circumstances. There isn't an automatic 50/50 rule.”
Emma: “So what does the prenup change?”
What Is a Section 90B Financial Agreement?
Under section 90B of the Family Law Act 1975, couples contemplating marriage can enter into a written Financial Agreement, commonly known as a prenuptial agreement or Binding Financial Agreement (BFA).
It allows couples to make arrangements in advance about how specified property, financial resources and maintenance matters will be dealt with if their marriage breaks down.
For example, a Financial Agreement may address:
-
Pre-marriage assets: Whether each party will retain properties, savings and investments they owned before marriage.
-
Businesses: How a business owned by one party will be treated if the marriage breaks down.
-
Assets acquired during marriage: How property and investments acquired during the marriage will be divided.
-
Debts and liabilities: How specified debts will be allocated between the parties.
-
Inheritances and gifts: How certain inheritances or gifts will be treated.
-
Spousal maintenance: Arrangements for financial support, subject to legal requirements.
Can a Financial Agreement Protect Both Partners?
Emma: “So Daniel can use a Financial Agreement to protect his houses and business?”
Lawyer: “That may be one of the objectives. But a Financial Agreement can also address your financial interests and future circumstances. It's important to consider the proposed terms as a whole.”
Emma: “What do you mean?”
Lawyer: “For example, you mentioned that you and Daniel plan to have children. What happens if you reduce your working hours or stop working to look after your family?”
Emma: “I'd probably have to put my career on hold for a while.”
Lawyer: “That's something worth considering when negotiating financial arrangements. Your circumstances may look very different in ten or fifteen years.”
Emma thought for a moment.
Emma: “So the agreement doesn't have to say Daniel keeps everything?”
Lawyer: “No. The terms are matters for negotiation. You should understand what financial rights you may be giving up and whether the proposed arrangements meet your needs.”
Emma: “What happens if we don't sign a prenup?”
Lawyer: “If you separate and cannot agree on property settlement, either of you may apply to the Court for financial orders, subject to the applicable requirements and time limits. The Court would consider your circumstances under the family law legislation.”
Emma: “And if we do sign?”
Lawyer: “A binding Financial Agreement can determine the financial matters covered by it instead of having those matters decided under the Court's usual property settlement process.”
Emma looked concerned.
Emma: “That sounds like a big decision.”
Lawyer: “It is. That's why you should never treat a Financial Agreement as a document you simply sign to make your partner or their family happy.”
Emma picked up her phone.
Emma: “I think Daniel and I need to have another conversation.”
But when she told Daniel what she had learned, he had another surprise for her.
Daniel: “Mum has already asked the family lawyer to prepare the agreement. She said we can both just go in and sign it.”
Emma stared at him.
Emma: “Wait. Your family's lawyer? Is that even allowed?”
To be continued…
📖 NEXT IN PART 3: “Can a Financial Agreement Be Overturned?”
Emma and Daniel explore what makes a Binding Financial Agreement legally binding and the essential requirements to ensure it cannot be set aside by the court.